Build vs. buy: why purpose-built UX research tools win over DIY systems

If you’ve ever tried to run user research operations from Airtable, spreadsheets, or even Salesforce, you know the drill. At first, the flexibility feels liberating - you can create exactly what you want, exactly how you want it. (You work in UX; this is your dream.)

But as your research program grows, so does the complexity. The spreadsheets get bigger. The automations get messier. The troubleshooting gets constant. Before long, “custom” starts to feel more like “fragile.”

That’s where purpose-built platforms like Rally come in. Instead of building your own research CRM from scratch, Rally gives you everything you need to recruit, manage, and communicate with participants out of the box.

Here’s a look at the key differences between building your own and buying a tool designed specifically for UXR.

Bandwidth to Build

Airtable, Salesforce, and Excel don’t come prepackaged with "UX Research Project CRM" templates - you have to build them. Developing anything beyond a barebones spreadsheet requires getting the right stakeholders in the room, securing IT approvals, managing data compliance, and convincing other teams to prioritize your project.

If you have the organizational influence, technical know-how, and time to design and maintain your own participant management system, it can work. But most research teams are already stretched thin, meaning these projects can stall before they get off the ground. Rally skips all that and gets you running in days, not months.

Blank Canvases vs. Purpose-Built Workflows

General-purpose tools give you a blank slate. That’s great for flexibility, but it also means you start with… nothing.

You have to design and maintain:

• Tagging systems
• Contact rules
• Recruitment workflows
• Participation history
• Segmentation logic

Even basic research needs like screeners, quotas, and templates don’t exist - you have to bolt them on with forms, scripts, and integrations. Salesforce has similar challenges - it’s built for sales, not research - so custom UXR workflows often require expensive admin or dev support.

Rally starts with all of this already in place, based on proven best practices from research teams of all sizes.

Operational Resilience at Scale

Airtable can be a dream for one person, but a headache for ten. As more researchers, PMs, and designers join in, you’re constantly:

• Troubleshooting automation errors
• Reconciling stale or duplicated lists
• Enforcing participant cooldowns manually 
• Manage growing user costs

Without a true collaboration model, one person’s change can break another’s workflow. Over time, you’re left with a system only one or two people truly understand. Rally is built for team use, with guardrails and governance baked in so the system stays stable as you grow.

Moreover, you probably picked Airtable because multiple departments were already using it, but that means someone else could eat up all the automation, AI, or attachment credits needed to run your latest project. (And UX projects rarely get priority over billing, procurement, or operations tasks).

End-to-End Research Workflows

Participant management is only part of the job a homegrown Research Ops tool has to tackle. You also need:

• Automated scheduling & reminders
• Built-in screeners & quota enforcement
• Incentive tracking
• Governance controls

DIY systems require patching these together with Zapier, Google Forms, Mailchimp, and other tools - a setup that can be brittle and time-consuming. Rally gives you all of these in one place, fully integrated, and ready to use.

Participant History & Relationship Management

In DIY setups, participant data is often siloed. (A spreadsheet is not a database.) There’s no easy way to:

• Track participation across studies
• Enforce automatic cooldowns
• Prevent duplicate outreach
• Map screener/survey data to participant profiles over time

This makes it hard to build long-term panels or run targeted recruitment. Rally automatically keeps a complete history for each participant, giving you a real CRM for your research community.

Governance & Collaboration

Excel, Google Sheets, and Airtable lack robust permissions - you can either edit an entire spreadsheet or you can't update it at all, full stop. Anyone can change anything, leading to inconsistent processes and compliance risk.

Rally provides a centralized governance model with custom roles and permissions, so ReOps can stay in control while enabling the whole team to contribute in only the ways that they need to.

Protecting Sensitive Data

In DIY tools, personally identifiable information (PII) often ends up in plain view. Without masking or role-based access, sensitive participant details can be exposed across your company. Rally protects participant privacy by default, with built-in PII controls and access restrictions.

Total Cost of Ownership

On paper, Airtable or spreadsheets might seem cheaper. But factor in:

• Hours spent designing and maintaining the system
• Cost of third-party tools for scheduling, screening, and incentives
• Risk of compliance issues
• Downtime when something breaks

The real cost of a DIY or vibe-coded tool can easily exceed the price of a purpose-built platform -- especially when you factor in the opportunity cost of time lost to operational overhead.

The Right Tool for the Right Job

Building your own UXR CRM can be rewarding if you have the time, budget, technical resources, and political capital to make it happen. But for many teams, the hidden costs, operational fragility, and lack of UXR-specific features outweigh the benefits.

Rally gives you a purpose-built user research CRM so you can focus on doing great work, not fixing spreadsheets.

‍

Curious how Rally could replace your homegrown system? Book a demo and see how quickly your ReOps squad can be up and running - without waiting for a new DIY tool to come online.